CyRisk vs Bitsight, SecurityScorecard and KYND: which fits cyber underwriting?
All four read an organization’s risk from the outside. Bitsight and SecurityScorecard are security ratings platforms used across vendor risk, security teams and insurance. KYND and CyRisk focus on insurance. CyRisk stands apart by confirming what is truly exploitable, covering zero-days before they reach CISA’s catalog, and giving policyholders a loss-control program backed by expert services.
At a glance
How the four compare for insurers.
A factual side-by-side based on what each company publishes about its own product. Each is a capable tool; the right choice depends on the job you need done.
| CyRisk | Bitsight | SecurityScorecard | KYND | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Built for | Cyber insurance only: underwriting, portfolio management and loss control. | Security ratings used for third-party risk, security performance and cyber insurance. | Security ratings used for supply-chain risk, security teams and cyber insurance. | Cyber risk intelligence for insurers, brokers and organizations of any size. |
| Score | 0–1000 score, plus category dials that estimate how likely each type of loss is. | Rating on a 250–900 scale, refreshed daily, with A–F grades for each risk vector. | Score from 0–100 with an A–F letter grade, built from 10 risk factors. | A color-coded view of more than 250 risk factors, with vulnerability detail rather than a single black-box score. |
| How it’s built | Generated fresh at scan time for each submission. No agents, credentials or applicant cooperation. | Continuous observation of an organization’s internet-facing footprint, with more than 10 years of historical ratings data. | Continuous scanning of the internet for vulnerabilities and risk signals, with real-time and historical views. | External scanning with fresh scans for real-time attribution, with insights in as little as 90 seconds. |
| Exploit validation | Yes. For RED findings, a human analyst confirms each known exploited vulnerability non-destructively on that host, and ZED flags exploited zero-days before they reach CISA’s catalog. | Not described in its published materials. | Not described in its published materials. | Not described in its published materials. |
| Privacy exposure | Yes. InsightEngine · Privacy scores privacy litigation risk (tracking pixels, session replay, consent) and maps findings to the claim theories a plaintiff’s firm could use, before bind. | Not a focus of its published cyber-underwriting materials. | Not a focus of its published cyber-insurance materials. | A privacy summary report for underwriters, plus published research on website tracking without consent. |
| AI exposure | Yes, built for the underwriting decision. InsightEngine · AI Underwriting reads the public record and the broker’s application together, flags where they disagree, rates AI risk by coverage line, and ends with a Write, Write with conditions or Refer recommendation. Every finding links to its source. | Not a focus of its published cyber-underwriting materials. | Not a focus of its published cyber-insurance materials. | AI discovery that identifies externally visible AI technologies at risk selection, launched September 2026 to supplement proposal forms. |
| Across the book | RED Scan finds known exploited vulnerabilities and risky exposed services across every insured; ZED flags exploited zero-days not yet on CISA’s catalog. | Risk trends, diversification, accumulation and catastrophe views for portfolio management. | Continuous portfolio monitoring and cyber risk quantification. | Exposure management for accumulation and catastrophe scenarios, with loss projections. |
| For policyholders | CyRisk Protect loss-control platform, plus vCISO, vCPO and vCAIO advisory services and white glove support. | Risk control tools to collaborate with insureds on strengthening their posture. | Guidance that helps insureds understand and reduce their risk. | KYND ON, a monitoring platform with real-time alerts on emerging threats, offered through insurers. |
Competitor details are summarized from each company’s public website as of November 2026 and may change: Bitsight ratings guide, Bitsight cyber underwriting, SecurityScorecard scoring, SecurityScorecard for cyber insurance, KYND, KYND AI discovery, KYND exposure management, KYND ON. Bitsight, SecurityScorecard and KYND are trademarks of their respective owners; this page is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of them.
When each one fits
Pick the tool for the job.
CyRisk is a strong fit when you want to…
- Score a submission fresh at quote time, without waiting on the applicant.
- Price cyber and privacy exposure together, with AI exposure on the same read.
- Go beyond spotting AI to know what it means for each coverage line, what to ask the broker and whether to write, condition or refer.
- Know which insureds are truly exploitable, confirmed by an analyst, and catch exploited zero-days before they reach CISA’s catalog.
- Give policyholders a loss-control program and real people to help them fix what was found.
Another tool may fit when you…
- Already use it for vendor or third-party risk and want one rating shared across teams.
- Need long rating history for trend analysis or modeling.
- Want a widely recognized grade to share with outside parties.
- Need catastrophe and accumulation scenario modeling inside the same exposure tool.
Many carriers use more than one tool: a ratings or modeling platform for long-run trend and accumulation, and CyRisk for a fresh read at bind, confirmed exploitability across the book and hands-on loss control.
Questions underwriters ask
Frequently asked questions.
Is CyRisk a security ratings company?
No. CyRisk scores risk from the outside, as ratings vendors do, but it is built only for insurance workflows. It reads cyber, privacy and AI exposure for each submission, monitors exploitable exposure across a book with the RED Scan, and gives policyholders a loss-control program through CyRisk Protect.
How does the CyRisk 0–1000 score compare with a Bitsight rating or a SecurityScorecard grade?
They use different scales and different methods, so they should not be converted into one another. CyRisk’s score is generated fresh at scan time for each submission. Bitsight publishes a 250–900 rating refreshed daily, and SecurityScorecard publishes a 0–100 score with an A–F grade.
How is CyRisk different from KYND?
Both focus on cyber insurance and read risk from the outside. CyRisk differs in four ways: a human analyst confirms each known exploited vulnerability non-destructively before it is reported; ZED flags exploited zero-days before they reach CISA’s catalog; the AI scan turns AI use into coverage-line exposure and a Write, Write with conditions or Refer recommendation, rather than detection alone; and policyholders get CyRisk Protect plus vCISO, vCPO, vCAIO and managed security services rather than monitoring alone.
How does CyRisk’s AI scan compare with AI discovery tools?
Discovery tools show that a company uses AI. CyRisk goes further for the underwriter: it checks the application against public evidence and flags contradictions, rates AI risk for each affected coverage line, lists conditions and broker questions before bind, and gives a Write, Write with conditions or Refer recommendation. Every finding links back to its source, and the report states how confident it is.
Can we use CyRisk alongside Bitsight, SecurityScorecard or KYND?
Yes. Many carriers keep a ratings or modeling platform for long-run trend, accumulation and vendor risk, and add CyRisk for an insurance-specific read at quote time, privacy and AI exposure, and book-level exploit checks.
Do security ratings cover privacy litigation risk?
Privacy exposure is not a focus of the published insurance materials from Bitsight or SecurityScorecard, and KYND offers a privacy summary report. CyRisk adds a privacy read of the applicant’s public website, covering tracking pixels, session replay and consent behavior, and maps each finding to the claim theories a plaintiff’s firm could use.
Can you underwrite cyber insurance without a questionnaire?
CyRisk is designed to read a submission from the outside with no applicant cooperation, so you can tier and price before the application arrives. Outside-in scanning cannot see internal controls such as backups or endpoint coverage, so many underwriters pair it with a short application.
How can we test CyRisk on our own business?
Send five past submissions and we will score them, so you can back-test the results against the underwriting calls you made. Start with the back-test request on the sample report page.
See CyRisk on your own submissions.
Back-test five past submissions, or book a walkthrough with our underwriting team.
